$2,350,000
172 5th Street, 11944
About this property
Available furnished, this recently renovated Greenport Village house in prized West Dublin neighborhood – one block to three beaches and just short walk to town and the jitney! Meticulously restored with historic charm which seamlessly blends into a large thoughtful addition. 9+ feet high ceilings on the first floor with original base, crown and molding details. The front living room leads to a charming side porch – perfect for morning coffee or evening relaxing time. The dining room features a wood burning fireplace and entrance to the modern kitchen. The addition of a family room with two walls of windows/sliding doors to take in the light and view of the private back yard with a heated salt water pool. Upstairs are three bedrooms with a new bathroom which includes a windowed shower. The addition of the primary suite at the back with cathedral, beamed ceiling, walk-in closet, hanging closet and ensuite primary bath featuring a large windowed shower with bench, shower, rain shower and handheld for a spa-like experience. The deep lot [extremely rare for Greenport village] provides the inground, heated, saltwater pool, generous space, garage and lush landscaping. In addition to the proximity to the beaches, the LIRR and Jitney are just minutes away as well as the heart of Greenport Village with all the waterfront, shops and restaurants it has to offer.
Features
Interior
- –First Floor Full Bath
- –Beamed Ceilings
- –Bidet
- –Built-in Features
- –Cathedral Ceiling(s)
- –Ceiling Fan(s)
- –Chandelier
- –Crown Molding
- –Formal Dining
- –Granite Counters
Exterior
- –Garden
- –Gas Grill
Appliances
- –Cooktop
- –Dishwasher
- –Dryer
- –Electric Oven
- –Freezer
- –Gas Cooktop
- –Microwave
- –Oven
- –Refrigerator
- –Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Heating
- –Electric
- –Forced Air
Cooling
- –Central Air
Parking
- –Driveway
Financial
- Annual taxes
- $8,791 (2026)
Listed by Compass Greater NY LLC
MLS# KEY948616
Represented by Nathalia Valencia, Nostra Haus · 631.488.0834
Interested in this property?
Request a showing and we’ll confirm a time within a few hours.
Save this property
Get a shareable link to your saved properties sent directly to your inbox.
See what sold nearby
Request a recent sold comps report for Greenport — delivered within 24 hours.
First time buying in the Hamptons?
Download our free buyer’s guide — CPF tax, closing costs, hamlet-by-hamlet breakdown.
Property details
- ZIP
- 11944
- Type
- Residential
- Style
- Single Family Residence
- Year built
- 1930
- Interior
- 1,900 sq ft
- Lot
- 0.19 acres
Similar listings in Greenport
View allListings courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS GRID.
Any unauthorized use or search of data on this website is prohibited.
The listing information set forth on this site is based upon information which we consider reliable, but because it has been supplied by third parties (including the multiple listing service and the listing brokerage), we cannot represent that it is accurate or complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. All offerings are subject to errors, omissions, changes including price, or withdrawal without notice. All dimensions, square footage, lot sizes, and other measurements are approximate and have not been independently verified by Nostra Haus Real Estate. Buyers are encouraged to engage qualified professionals — including appraisers, surveyors, inspectors, and attorneys — to independently verify any information that is material to their purchasing decision.